Northern Beaches Advocate: Pittwater residents opposed to overdevelopment have taken their concerns directly to the Parliament of NSW.
Shortly before midday yesterday (Wednesday, 21 October), around 100 protestors from the residents action group Save Our Suburb (SOS) Mona Vale rallied outside Parliament House at Macquarie Street, Sydney, to deliver a ‘technical dossier’ calling for an immediate halt to low and mid-rise (LMR) rezoning in Pittwater.
According to SOS convenor John David (image below, right), the dossier outlines planning constraints the NSW Government failed to take into consideration when designating Mona Vale as an LMR town centre.
“This dossier has been prepared following the admission by Paul Scully, the Minister for Planning and Public Spaces, that a detailed study of Mona Vale’s ability to safely sustain higher density was not conducted before it was rezoned.
“The Government has not done their homework, so we have done it for them,” said Mr David.
The group was supported by Pittwater Ward Greens Councillor Miranda Korzy (image below, left) who said the NSW Government had shown a ‘total disregard’ for the community.
“This government has shown a total disregard for the community with these so-called changes or so-called reforms. They’re actually just changes, they’re not reforms. They’re not improving things.
“They are actually just undermining communities and community cohesiveness and the environment while they’re at it. Democracies work on the principle that you give everybody a say, and local planning until now has been carried out by local councils,” said Cr Korzy.
Former Pittwater Council General Manager Angus Gordon OAM (image below, right), who is also a coastal management and environment engineer, elaborated on the constraints, saying more people would overwhelm water, sewerage and transport infrastructure.
“It is not planning if you have planning without infrastructure. It’s not simply incompetence; it’s irresponsible because at some point in time in the future, it’s going to have to be picked up and paid for by somebody.
“If you go back to the 1994 bushfires, we lost over 30 houses in Elanora [Heights], and we lost them because there wasn’t the water supply. Well, guess what? Sydney Water hasn’t upgraded the water supply, and yet the density has increased, and now they’re proposing greater increases,” said Mr Gordon.
Upper house MPs also addressed the crowd, including Liberal Member of the Legislative Council (MLC) and Shadow Parliamentary Secretary for Planning Rachel Merton.
“It’s absolutely critical that the community voice is heard on these issues. I’m seeing this all over Sydney, and I live pretty much in your area.
“I know the streets are full, the bus queues are full and they’re getting longer. There’s no transport, The Beaches Link [Tunnel] is never even spoken about. Then all of a sudden, we’ve got thousands of new homes coming.
“A couple of weeks ago, it was budget estimates. I had the Planning Minister in front of me, and I put the question to him, ‘Can you name one State Significant Development that you have knocked back on the grounds of no infrastructure?’ and he said not one.
“This is not a question about no housing, because the kids want to buy houses. The kids want to live in the same neighbourhood as mum and dad.
“But it’s got to be responsible, it’s got to be considered, and the community have to have a voice because a community is not just a block of units,” said Ms Merton.
SOS Mona Vale organisers presented their technical dossier to Northern Beaches MPs Michael Regan and Jacqui Scruby, who said they would take it into Parliament House to present to the Minister’s office.
Wakehurst MP Michael Regan called the Government’s plan ‘rubbish’, blamed the Liberals for supporting it, and asked for support at the upcoming election.
“This is a fight worth fighting. This HDA [Housing Delivery Authority] rubbish is bullshit. I have one at Warringah Mall, they want 39 storeys. 1,600 dwellings. 800 more than what [Northern Beaches] Council and the transport plan says. It is rubbish, so we need your voices.
“Jacqui and I, and The Greens were the only ones, it’s on the record, who actually voted against the planning reforms. If any Liberal or anyone tells you that they are going to change it, that’s rubbish. They could have changed it now.
“If re-elected, we’ll continue to fight it and try and repeal it,” vowed Mr Regan.
Pittwater MP Jacqui Scruby gave a speech (in full, video above) in which she also blamed the Liberals for supporting housing development and called affordable housing bonuses for developers a ‘loophole’ and ‘a scam’.
“We have another petition as well around affordability. That is basically calling out the government on their affordable housing loophole for developers, where they can get an extra couple of storeys and actually deliver housing that, particularly for our area, is not affordable and is not affordable in perpetuity. So it’s basically farcical. It’s a scam,” said Ms Scruby.
The dossier (full document) presented to the Parliament of NSW by the group outlines concerns and calls for an immediate moratorium on rezoning and densification.
- Sydney Water Warriewood Wastewater Treatment Plant is running over-capacity, discharging partially treated effluent at Turimetta
- The peninsula is a geographic cul-de-sac with limited routes in and out, creating a transport bottleneck
- Public transport is further constrained by physical pinch points such as The Spit and Military Road
- Development bonuses for affordable housing fails to deliver when the 30 percent rental discount remains well above key worker affordability
The dossier was received by Parliamentary Secretary for Planning and Public Spaces Stephen Bali, who met with a small delegation from the SOS Mona Vale group, including Mr David.
“I feel that, after today, our little community is a step closer to reclaiming control over its way forward,” said Mr David.
Dale Cohen